
The Effect of Cryonics on the Viability of Sea Urchin
Gametes
By Stephanie A., 9th grade
![]()
Contents:
The purpose of this experiment was to determine whether cryogenic affects the fertilization of sea urchin gametes freezing them at different lengths of time and regenerating them in three different ways. I became interested in this idea when I was looking through the Internet. The information gained from this experiment could someday help people decide whether they should be frozen or not in case there is ever a cure for a certain decease they might have.
My hypothesis was that the slower I regenerated the eggs, the more chances there were that the gametes would die. Also, the longer I froze the eggs and sperm, the greater the chance that they would fertilize. I based my hypothesis on an Internet web site called “Cryobiology- The analysis of the effects of extremely low temperatures on things.” The web site stated that regenerating the cells quicker would increase the chance for the cells to survive.
The constants in this study were:
- the type of sea urchins
- the equipment
- the microscope objectives
- the amount of potassium chloride injected in the sea urchin
- the amount of sea urchin eggs being frozen (5ml)
- the amount of sea urchin sperm being frozen (one single drop)
The manipulated variable was the different lengths of time I let the gametes stay cryopreserved. Another manipulated variable was the three different temperatures at which I regenerated the eggs and sperm.
The results of this experiment were that the longer I froze the gametes the greater percentage of them died and the slower I regenerated the eggs and sperm, the percentage of fertilized gametes increased. Therefore, the results indicate that my hypothesis should be rejected.
If I were to conduct this
experiment again, I would get an earlier start of planning the whole project. I
would make sure all my equipment is ordered and mailed to me long before I
start the experiment. If I were to use sea urchins again, I would make certain
the temperature of my aquarium is at a very low temperature.
The purpose of this experiment was to determine whether cryonics affects the
fertilization of sea urchin eggs and sperms cryopreserving the eggs and sperm
at different lengths of time and regenerating them in three different ways. I
became interested in this idea when I was looking through the Internet for science
project ideas. I came upon a web page that students all over the country had
put their ideas into to share with the world. The information gained from this
experiment could help people understand and learn more about what cryogenics
is. Also, the results of this experiment may help some people to decide whether
they should be frozen someday or not in case there is ever a cure for a certain
decease they might have. Furthermore, I will determine the effects of cold
storage on sex cells.
My hypothesis was that the slower I regenerated the gametes, the more
chances there were that the eggs and sperm would die. Also, the longer I froze the
eggs and sperm, the greater the chance that they would fertilize. I based my
hypothesis on an Internet web site called "Cryobiology- The analysis of
the effects of extremely low temperatures on things." The web site stated
that regenerating the cells quicker would increase the chance for the cells to
survive. Cooling rates are "slow" and "fast" depending on
whether heat leaves the cell more slowly or more quickly than the water does.
The extracellular solution almost always leaves first. The extracellular
solutes are concentrated in the remaining unfrozen extracellular water, and, if
cooling rates are slow enough, this dehydrates the cell by osmosis as water
diffuses from the cytoplasm into the more concentrated external solution.
The constants in this study were:
The manipulated variable was the different lengths of time I let the eggs and sperms stay cryopreserved in the liquid nitrogen. In addition, another manipulated variable was the three different temperatures at which I regenerated the eggs and sperm.
The responding variable was the percentage of eggs that were fertilized after the cryopreservation. To measure how many eggs were fertilized after the cryopreservation, I put the eggs under a microscope and randomly selected different sections of the petri dish and to zoom in on at100x. Then I counted, in total, how many eggs there were. Next, I counted how many eggs were fertilized. I repeated this ten times.
The controlled group in this experiment was the eggs and sperm that were not frozen, but had been observed right after the sea urchin released their eggs or sperm.
Quantity Item
Description Cost
to the experimenter
|
1 |
Dewer's Flask |
$0.00 |
|
30.32L (8 gallon) |
Liquid Nitrogen |
$43.04 |
|
36 |
Cryovials |
$102.00 |
|
50ml |
Potassium Chloride |
$0 |
|
10 |
Petri Dishes |
$0 |
|
1 |
Microscope |
$0 |
|
32 |
Sea Urchins |
$220.00 |
|
2 |
Hot Plate |
$0 |
|
2.2L (10gallons) |
Artificial sea water |
$16.99 |
|
3 |
Marine AQ. Gravel |
$20.22 |
|
1 |
Hydrometer |
$9.99 |
|
3 |
Glass pipette |
$0 |
|
3 |
Syringe |
$0 |
|
3 |
Stopwatch |
$0 |
|
50ml |
Ethanol |
$0 |
|
1 (2.2L or 10gallon) |
Aquarium |
$0 |
|
1 (100ml) |
Beaker |
$0 |
|
1 (24 shots) |
Film |
$0 |
|
1 |
Tong |
$0 |
|
1 |
Project board |
$0 |
|
3 |
Thermometer |
$0 |
|
1 pair |
Gloves |
$0 |
|
1 |
Goggle |
$0 |
|
1 |
Stirring Rod |
$0 |
|
3 (500ml) |
Beakers |
$0 |
|
2 (250ml) |
Beakers |
$0 |
|
5 |
slides |
$0 |
|
10 |
Cover Slips |
$0 |
The procedures I intend to use are:
- 1 day (room temp, level 1, level 2), trial 1, 2, or 3
1 week (room temp, level 1, level 2),
trial 1, 2, or 3
I. If the sea urchin is male:
a. After the male sea urchin has been injected, he is placed on a dry surface like a petri dish mouth side down.
b. After a minute or two you will start to see the white sperm appearing on the surface of the urchin.
c. Collect the sperm "dry" in a glass pipette or eyedropper and place it in a test tube. (Seawater "activates" the sperm reducing their life span from days to minutes. Keep concentrated until just before use.)
d. After you have collected all the sperm that you can, place the tube into a refrigerator if you don’t intend to use them immediately. Sperm will keep at 4C (39.2 F) for about 2-5 days.
e. Using the glass pipette put a single drop of sperm into each of the12 cryovials.
II. If the sea urchin is female:
a. After the female sea urchin has been injected, she is placed mouth side up over a beaker full of seawater. Eggs will not shed unless in contact with seawater. Beaker should be slightly smaller than the diameter of the sea urchin.
b. The eggs will be shed into the seawater and collected at the bottom of the beaker. This can take from 10-45 minutes for the female urchin to finish shedding the eggs.
c. It is best to keep the eggs and urchin at the same temperature.
d. Mix the eggs gently with a stirring rod and using a glass pipette put 5mL of eggs into each of the 12 cryovials.
a. After 30 minutes:
1. Pre-heat the two hot plates and fill three beakers 2/3 full of water.
2. Take two beakers and put one on each of the hot plates.
3. Take out the 6 cryovials (3 eggs and 3 sperm) out of the dewer’s flask with tongs and wipe the cryovials with ethanol or isopropanal. Put one cryovial from each onto a beaker until it is completely melted.
4. Take another cryovial from each and expose both on a hot plate until it is completely melted.
5. Take the last two cryovials and put it under another hot plate but at a different temperature until it is completely melted.
6. Make sure to release the pressure building up inside the cryovials. Don’t open the cryovial all the way just halfway.
7. When the cryovials are completely melted, mix the eggs and the sperm together in one petri dish.
8. Wait for 2 minutes for the eggs to fertilize.
9. After 2 minutes, take the petri dish and put it under a microscope.
10. Once the microscope is focused, randomly select different sections of the petri dish and zoom in 100x.
11. Count how many, in total, eggs there are. Then count how many eggs there are fertilized and how many that is not fertilized.
12. Do the counting ten times.
b. After 5 hours:
1. Follow steps 1-12 in part ‘a’
c. After 1 day:
1. Follow steps 1-12 in part ‘a’.
d. After 3 days:
1. Follow steps 1-12 in part ‘a’.
e. After 1 week:
1. Follow steps 1-12 in part ‘a’.
1. Repeat steps 1- 7 two more times to make sure your data is accurate.
2. After you have done 3 trials of steps 1-7 do steps 2-5 for the controlled group.
3. In the controlled group you will take 5ml of eggs and a drop of sperm and put them in a petri dish.
4. Let it stand for about two minutes for it to fertilize.
5. Put it under a microscope and randomly select different sections of the petri dish and count how many eggs there are in total and how many are fertilized.
Do the counting ten times.
|
Date Time Procedures/Observations 11-16-98 55min. My teacher started to talk about science projects. He gave out information on how the to do one. Afterwards I looked at other previous project boards. 30min. I went on the Internet and looked for science project ideas. I found one that looked interesting about cryogenic. 11-17-98 5min. I saw Mr. Brown in the hallway while going to the library. I talked to him briefly about the topic cryogenic. 55min. I went on the Internet and looked for information about cryonics. I found none that fit my idea or any that I needed. 11-18-98 120min. I talked with Mr. Brown after school and talked about my project. He made the idea more clear to me. 11-19-98 50min. I went to the school library and looked for books about cells. I found two that looked good and checked it out. 15min. I called Mr. Brown after school and talked about what kind of cells I should freeze. 40min. I went on the Internet and looked for subjects like cryogenics, freezing cells, embryos, and in-vitro fertilization. I wrote some information down that I thought was interesting. I also thought of some variable I could do on how and what to test. But I got confused and stopped and decided to wait to until
I talked with Mr. Mcmillen. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
11-20-98 10min. Talked with Mr. McMillen about my topic and about the paperwork. 20min. Talked again with Mr. McMillen after school about new ideas and how to get equipment and specimens. 11-21-98 60min. I went on the Internet and looked at the two sites Mr. McMillen gave to me. I also, looked for other good sites that would fit my project. I found one about in-vitro fertilization. It looked really interesting so I wrote down the web address and later I will put it in my bibliography. 11-24-98 30min. I went on the Internet and found one very good site. It will help me a lot; wrote down the address. I read some of it. 11-25-98 45min. I went to Mr. Brown and talked about whom to go to, to find information and advance on my project. He said I should talk to any doctor who has connections with other doctors in the field of cryobiology. 11-30-98 15min. I called my doctor (Dr. Gondo) and asked if he could help me with my project. Also, if I could use his lab and if he is willing to supervise me. He said yes but he needed more information. 12-1-98 10min. Worked on project. 12-2-98 20min. I went to the library and thought up of a good title. I found none that I liked. 45min. I went to Mr. Brown after school and got my ISEF forms. Talked more about my project. 60min. I talked with my uncle in San Francisco chemical engineer and talked about my project. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
liquid nitrogen. I also made a rough draft of everything to show to Mr. Mcmillen. I made sure I have everything all set so when the sea urchins come in I will be ready. 1-4-99 10min. Mr.Mcmillen was gone so I couldn’t show him my rough draft. After school I went to Ms. Gustin’s |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
1-19-99 180min. The Sea Urchins came early so I had to rush to do the experiment because I didn’t want the sea urchins to die again. I went and got the liquid nitrogen and then went to Dr. Gondo’s office. Before I started the experiment I forgot to bring salt water so I had to go back home and get salt water for the female urchin. The first sea urchin I injected was a female and it was releasing its eggs for about 45 minutes before it stopped. Next I got a male. Not a lot of sperm came out so I had to put more potassium chloride each time it stopped releasing. I did the controlled group then put the eggs and sperm in cryovials. I put the cryovials in the liquid nitrogen. I didn’t have time to do the 15-minute trial so I changed that to a one-day trial. 1-20-99 180min. After school I went and got the liquid nitrogen and then went to Dr. Gondo’s office to do the experiment. I brought five urchins with me today and I didn’t get either egg or sperm in all of them. Most were already weak when I brought them. After waiting an hour to see if any will release just in case I next took out the one day trial cryovials out of the dewer’s flask. I regenerated the eggs and sperm three different ways. I mixed the eggs and sperm and got the results. 1-21-99 130min. Again after school I went and got the liquid |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
nitrogen and went to Dr. Gondo’s office to do the experiment. I again tried to do the second trial experiment. This time it released a lot of eggs but not much sperm. I did get enough for the experiment though. I put them all in the dewer’s flask. I didn’t regenerate anything today. I also started my third trial today. 1-22-99 150min. I went and got the liquid nitrogen at the Yakima Welders Supply. When I to my doctors office I started the experiment once I got all my equipment ready. I took out of the flask the three-day cryovials trial one. I also regenerated second and third trials for the one-day experiment. I regenerated the eggs and sperm in three different ways and mixed the eggs and sperm together. I put drops of it into a slide and looked at it under the microscope and wrote down the results. 30min. After I finished my experiment I made sure I cleaned up everything. Then I edited my procedures and typed more in my experiment log and pre-experiment log. 1-24-99 180min. I got ready to go get my liquid nitrogen and then go to my doctor’s office to do the experiment. Today I regenerated trial two and three for the three-day trial. There were some eggs that fertilized and that was amazing because I didn’t expect that. But there was very little. The eggs doesn’t look like the eggs when they were fresh but it is more very light yellow and it looks as if it’s |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
cracked in the inside. The ring around the eggs was not easily visible but can still see. 45min. I tried adding more information to my research report but I was really tired so I just typed more in my experiment log and again changed my procedures because today I decided that I will continue the 30 minute trial and the 5 hour trial. I did this part at home. 1-25-99 210min. After school I went to go get my liquid nitrogen and then went to Dr. Gondo’s office. I started my 30 minute and 5 hour trials. It took about an hour and a half for each trial to regenerate. I again found eggs that were alive in both 15 minute and 5 hour trials. This time there was more eggs that were fertilized. 1-26-99 85min. After school I went to Mr. Mcmillen’s room to discuss about some questions that I had. I asked him about the digital camera and when I could use it. He said to come in on Thursday after school. We hooked up the digital camera just to make sure it would work when I am ready to use it. I also asked about what my title should be because I’m still not sure which one to use. I also told him that I needed about 2 weeks after the due date for the project. It’s okay with him. 60min. I went to the Yakima Welder’s Supply and got the liquid nitrogen then went to my doctor’s office to do the last trial for my trial one. None of the eggs were alive and that didn’t really surprise me because the |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
percentage of live eggs kept going down as the legnth of time they were in the flask continued. I cleaned up and went home. 180min. I updated my experiment log and typed more. I started to graph my results on the computer but it doesn’t look right so I figure I will have Mr. Mcmillen look at it on Thursday. 1-27-98 45min. I went to Yakima Welder’s Supply and got my flask re-filled with liquid nitrogen. I graphed more of my results. It really takes a long time to make the graphs. I figured that I’d have around forty-five graphs and data to go with each one of them. I don’t know how I’ll be able to fit it all on my board. 1-28-99 60min. After school I went to Mr. Mcmillens room and asked him what time I could come in to use his digital camera to take pictures of dead urchin eggs. He said to come in around six o’clock. I regenerated the gametes at around four o’clock and then got ready to go to Mr. Mcmillen. 140min. I went to Mr. Mcmillens room and we started to set up the equipment. We didn’t see any of the eggs fertilizing so we didn’t get any pictures of the eggs fertilizing after being frozen. We only got to take still pictures of dead urchin eggs. What we did find was that there was living protist swimming around eating the dead eggs. They must have survived the freezing temperatures. When we tried to look for more of the protists in the eggs only vile, we |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
couldn’t find any so I assume they came from the sperm. But I can’t be sure of that since I didn’t look at the sperm only because I didn’t have any extra vials that had sperm only. |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
2-2-99 120min. I continued on making my graphs. I finished all of trial one and I started trial two. 2-5-99 45min. In class, Mr. Mcmillen talked about what we should have in our Pre-experiment log, Post-experiment log, Experiment log, Conclusion, and Scientific Error section. We took notes. After that, we were put into different groups and we would exchange journals of what we had and edit each other’s. During that time, I asked him about the laptop I’m going to borrow. He said that he has to check them out of the library and see if it worked. 2-6-99 190min. I finished making the rest of the graphs but I still need to edit it before I print it all out. I also have to show it to Mr. Mcmillen to see if it’s all right. 2-7-99 60min. I started to edit all the work in my journal. I also started to create my title, abstract, results, conclusion, and appendix. I don’t have my science binder with me which included the instructions on how to do the results and conclusion so I can’t continue far with that part of the journal. 2-9-99 45min. I started to analyze my results. I wrote part my results and conclusion. I printed two graphs but decided that I had to make changes. It didn’t look right and I really have to go and show Mr. Mcmillen this sometime. 2-10-99 30min. I went in to see Mr. Mcmillen today after school and
I asked him about the laptop. He said that I should start creating it two
weeks before I go to |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
check says that its wrong and I have to ask. I also printed what I can for my board. First, I need to get a board though. I updated my bibliography and added more. 2-15-99 5min. I printed off my abstract to show to Mr. Mcmillen because its over 250 words and I need to make sure that that’s ok with him and that he won’t down grade me on it. I changed it from a thousand and more words from around four hundred words. It’s really short now. 2-16-99 30min. I went in to Mr. Mcmillen’s room after school to show him the graphs that I made. He said that I should change it so that the graph will be over a period of time and not at the length of time I had them in. I also showed him my abstract to see if it was ok with him because it was way over 250 words. I asked him if I could print the pictures that I took with the digital camera. There were people on the computers so I had to wait. I didn’t get to print anything off except the dead eggs but that wasn’t any good so were going to do it again. 30min. I tried to change the graphs like what Mr. Mcmillen sai | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||